ccie, vcp ccvp, rhce, giac, gcih, cisco, netscreen, netscaler, juniper, f5, security, virtualization, vmware

OpenStack Nerd, CCIE, DevOps Junkie

Changing the world, one person at a time

OpenStack Nerd, CCIE, DevOps Junkie header image 2

VMware’s Acquisition of Nicira – VMware confirming the hypervisor is dead

July 23rd, 2012 · 3 Comments · CISCO, Cisco UCS, OpenStack, Unified Computing, virtualization, vmware, vSphere

VMware recently announced its intent to acquire Nicira for 1.2 billion dollars. This acquisition is of interest because it clearly signals VMware’s abandoning of the Hypervisor as a differentiating platform.

VMware tombstone

Yes, the hypervisor is commodity now. Whether it is ESXi, Hyper-V, Xen or KVM. You can take multiple operating systems and virtualize them on one CPU, share memory as well as do a live migration between hosts on all platforms.

Not only have commonly used features listed above become available across many platforms, but in some cases open source technologies such as KVM be more extensible then VMware’s product.

What is VMware thinking?

For the past couple years, VMware has been investing in technologies outside of the hypervisor. Some of this include Cloud Automation, Virtual Desktop, Application security and control, and Operations and Management.

These investments are smart, because it transforms the conversation from a discussion about hypervisors (which is a hard one to win on its own merits) to a discussion about the value add of all of the products that VMware offers.

Bundling of products and services is business 101 when your product becomes commoditized. Cisco does it by integrating all aspects of their product lines, EMC does it by offering a range of integrated Tier 1-4 storage and backup solutions, and VMware does it by offering significantly more then a hypervisor.

I believe that this is the first step in VMware integrating their services into NON-ESXi hypervisors. Here is why –¬†

A few key concepts have emerged to be true in the virtualization market

1. Integrating multiple hypervisor support into their management platform (Systems Center Operations Manager – SCOM) is something customers want.

2. Customers are willing to utilize “Free” hypervisors such as Hyper-V or KVM / Xen for at minimum second or third their applications. And in some cases such as cloud service providers they are using these (specifically KVM and Xen) for their tier one virtualization.

3. The Cloud Service provider market is booming. It is not possible to compete on cost in that market while running on anything but Open Source hypervisors.

What the acquisition of Nicira gives Nicira is an integration point between all of the rich applications that have been developed since ESXi and Hyper-V, Xen and KVM (OpenStack).

Nicira already has plugins and to each of those platforms, providing not only a richly developed code base, but a conduit for linking disparate clouds together.

Does this signal an end to the honeymoon between VMware and Cisco?

The partnership between VMware and Cisco has been one based on mutual benefit, not mutual exclusivity.

The fact of the matter is that Cisco has been working with multiple Hypervisor’s for a long time now. ESXi, Hyper-V, Xen and KVM are all supported platforms on their Unified Computing Platform (UCS). Just the same as VMware was working with HP and Dell long before Cisco started making servers.

If you look close, you will notice that Cisco has been a major player in the OpenStack project. So much that there is EXTREMELY RICH integration with OpenStack’s Quantum Networking service in both UCS and the Nexus switching platform.

What this shows is that Cisco is presenting itself as a network and systems platform for Virtualization software manufacturers to leverage. Nicira has networking functions, but then so does the distributed vSwitch. At the end of the day, logical switching still needs physical devices. This is still a place where Cisco can and will play РAs an arms dealer to software manufacturers

Summing it all up

The hypervisor is dead, for VMware to stay relevant it has to continue innovating higher up the stack. The acquisition of Nicira will allow VMware to have a play in the service provider market and do just that.

It also provides an avenue for VMware to port it’s higher level applications to run on multiple hypervisors. This has the potential to slow flow of customers to free platforms like Hyper-V and OpenStack.

While this isn’t the best thing for the Cisco relationship, the reality of the matter is that VMware and Cisco have an “Open” relationship where both companies work with many others. I don’t see this relationship changing in the long run.



Tags: ····

3 responses so far ↓

  • 1 joe brunner // Oct 29, 2013 at 10:27 pm

    This article is quite crap. Vmware esxi is an order of magnitude better than hyper-v.

    Where do I start?
    I spent weeks with citrix xen getting ubuntu to not restart into read-only mode. It has issues supporting many guest os’s.

    I spent more than a few evenings trying to replicate the vnic/vkernel functionality in hyper-v where a vswitch can use discrete physical nic’s per function.

    Hyper-v and citrix xen are primitive, basic and ancient to even the functionality afforded in vmware esxi 4.

    I would say vmware’s #1 asset – the one all the fortune 500’s still pay 2000 to 5000 per socket to license is the best, most stable, feature rich hypervisor and management utility (vsphere) in the world. This is my finding as of October 2013 having working again with Citrix Xen and Hyper-V again recently.

  • 2 Karl Pedersen // Dec 1, 2013 at 12:41 pm

    @joe brunner

    I think what he is trying to say is VMware is trying to layer itself with other products and options.

    Microsoft is catching up and will get there in due time. Marketing, Price, power relationships with vendors.

  • 3 colinmcnamara // Feb 12, 2014 at 6:53 am

    Well put Karl. And btw, if you look at the recent focus in VMware, you will see that their investments are going north of the hypervisor as it becomes an indefensible value portion of their portfolio.

    Higher layers of abstraction, IaaS layers, Service Catalogs, and PaaS frameworks are where the focus is moving too. It’s the evolution of tech. Constant forward movement is the only sure thing.

Leave a Comment